The foundational theorists of this week’s readings, Freud and Foucault, provide alternative but compatible models for understanding what an archive is and how it functions. Freud explains how an individual’s perceptual system gathers sensory input and how permanent traces are laid in the mnemic systems that store/archive these memories. He likens this operation to what is called the mystic writing pad. I will date myself by saying a magic slate (wunderblock) was one of my favorite childhood toys. Its only disadvantage was that it didn’t last long. The point would break off of the wooden writing stylus, dead spots would develop on the writing surface or the sheet of gray plastic film under the transparent cover would rip- a metaphor for dementia-or the fragility of an ephemeral archive. According to Freud our mental apparatus is like a tabula rasa with unlimited receptive capacity and the ability to preserve permanent memory traces intact. The problem is we can alter our recollections of what has occurred and memories may not always be accessed either whole or in fragments.
Foucault complicates the traditional definition of an archive. Instead of defining it as a specific place (library, warehouse) or thing (document, evidence) for him it as a system that determines what can and cannot be said and how what IS said is transformed into statements and events that become a part of discourse. It as also a positive dimension, a plane, where transformations occur. He is not interested in historical truth but in uncovering the structures and rules that govern how discourses are constructed and how they are dispersed through time. Freud’s focus is the individual Foucault’s is societal and systemic.
Agamben returns the individual (the speaking subject) to the center of a Foucauldian discussion by introducing the testimony of a witness. He sees it as the relationship between the possibility of speech and its actual occurrence giving voice to those for whom speech is impossible.
The artists show the influence of Freudian and Foucauldian theories in life and in art. I found these accounts to be interesting and instructive. Merewether groups them into those that resonate with Freud (Boltanski, Kabakov in counterpoint to Warhol, and Hiller) and those that align with Foucault (Green). It is pathetic that we have lost the boundary between spaces of garbage and non-garbage (my house will attest to this) and ennobling that humans try desperately to leave some tangible trace that would prevent death from erasing evidence of their/our existence. I identified with Hiller’s attempts to create interventions by finding connections between cast-off objects that resonated with her personally and more universal concepts. Her example of dealing with her feelings about sexual insult by placing cow creamers and a photo of a cowgirl toting a phallic pistol within a vitrine in Freud’s house was intriguing. For me, it is the artists accounts that flesh out the theory and make it real and relevant. They create traces in an archive of a 20th c. discourse.
Sunday, February 3, 2008
Traces and the Meaning of the Archive
I particularly liked Freud’s piece, which likened The Mystic Writing Pad to the physical structure of our memory apparatus in our minds – as if our mind could possibly have a physical structure. Maybe it does. But, what a funny thing to decide to do – map out the structure of the mind. It seems like something that could never be proven yet we lend his ideas so much precedence today. In a way, this makes me somewhat hopeful for the human race – that we can give authority to something that is so abstract, such as the archive.
Boltanski’s idea that we hoard or collect objects, words, moments in our past because we want to be immortal, I think is partly correct. But, I also think that because we fear death – perhaps that is the same as wanting to be immortal - we have a need to hold onto the past so that we can pretend that we are still living in it.
The excerpt from Warhol’s “The Philosophy of Andy Warhol” reminded me of something that my father is doing right now. He decided to remodel his house so that he can rent it out and save for retirement. During the remodel and rental he is going to live in an Airstream trailer. For the past year now he has been going through all of his stuff trying to decide what he absolutely has to keep and what he should get rid of. It has been an agonizing process – I think because it is not only getting rid of his own past, but his parent’s, grandparent’s, great grandparent’s, etc as well. Yet, he came to a point where he just wanted everyone to take everything far away – like New Jersey. At one point he thought he might put everything in unlabeled boxes and let his friends take however many they wanted. I actually wanted many of the things that he was giving away, many of which he couldn’t believe I was interested in. But, certain objects remind each person differently about events in their pasts.
I was again reminded of my Dad when Kabakov wrote, “But if you don’t do these sortings, these purges, and you allow the flow of paper to engulf you, considering it impossible to separate the important from the unimportant – wouldn’t that be insanity?” My Dad often allowed for the paper as well as the accumulation of objects to engulf him – you should have seen his office – and he often referred to it as insanity. So perhaps creating an archive is an attempt to remain sane.
I loved what Susan Hiller wrote about her installation at the Freud Museum and the creation of her own archive, which commented at times on the archive that it was placed in. Hiller said, “If you think of Freud’s notion of the dream as a narrative that had both a manifest and a hidden content, this might have something to do with the relationship between the story told by the story-teller and the story that was being heard.” If the story is an archive then what comes across from the contents of the archive may be quite different that the message that was intended with the formation of the archive. I think in some ways this is the beauty of an archive – that it can mean something quite different from one person to the next.
Boltanski’s idea that we hoard or collect objects, words, moments in our past because we want to be immortal, I think is partly correct. But, I also think that because we fear death – perhaps that is the same as wanting to be immortal - we have a need to hold onto the past so that we can pretend that we are still living in it.
The excerpt from Warhol’s “The Philosophy of Andy Warhol” reminded me of something that my father is doing right now. He decided to remodel his house so that he can rent it out and save for retirement. During the remodel and rental he is going to live in an Airstream trailer. For the past year now he has been going through all of his stuff trying to decide what he absolutely has to keep and what he should get rid of. It has been an agonizing process – I think because it is not only getting rid of his own past, but his parent’s, grandparent’s, great grandparent’s, etc as well. Yet, he came to a point where he just wanted everyone to take everything far away – like New Jersey. At one point he thought he might put everything in unlabeled boxes and let his friends take however many they wanted. I actually wanted many of the things that he was giving away, many of which he couldn’t believe I was interested in. But, certain objects remind each person differently about events in their pasts.
I was again reminded of my Dad when Kabakov wrote, “But if you don’t do these sortings, these purges, and you allow the flow of paper to engulf you, considering it impossible to separate the important from the unimportant – wouldn’t that be insanity?” My Dad often allowed for the paper as well as the accumulation of objects to engulf him – you should have seen his office – and he often referred to it as insanity. So perhaps creating an archive is an attempt to remain sane.
I loved what Susan Hiller wrote about her installation at the Freud Museum and the creation of her own archive, which commented at times on the archive that it was placed in. Hiller said, “If you think of Freud’s notion of the dream as a narrative that had both a manifest and a hidden content, this might have something to do with the relationship between the story told by the story-teller and the story that was being heard.” If the story is an archive then what comes across from the contents of the archive may be quite different that the message that was intended with the formation of the archive. I think in some ways this is the beauty of an archive – that it can mean something quite different from one person to the next.
Tracing Archives through Language and Objects
Tracing Archives and their meanings are created through objects within space and the historicity of language. Boltanksi believes traces of life is based on objects we are surrounded by which represent who we are. In addition, Boltanski believes language about what we've said and has been said about us. However, I am perplexed at how we can store these objects and statements in a so-called safe place. In reality, is there anywhere that can be considered "safe?" Foucault's Archaelogy of Knowledge informs us how langue transforms and never neutralizes the meaning of archives. Although Foucault never uses an actual archive as an example to his theory that text/language/statements constantly changes the historical meaning of archives, there is no need for Foucault to use an archive example because the physical objects contained within an archive does not change. Instead, through the archaeological digs of what has been said within a discursive systems about archives, it is our duty to question those statements so its meaning can never be neutral. I find this to be much more interesting than Susan Hiller's account of the objects within the Freud Museum's archive. Although Hiller discusses that the utilization of an archive is used to creating new meaning, I am not very interested in Hiller's personal recollections of the Freud's personal collection. Why do I care about Hiller's personal statements -- Is this for me the "garbage" that the plumber that Kabakov is referring to in his text? I am more concerned about the underpinnings in term of our theoretical understandings of the traces that create historical meaning for archives through what Agamben calls the "possibility/impossibility, potentiality/impotentiality, the said/unsaid" of langue.
Saturday, February 2, 2008
Traces
While reading "Traces," very appropriately named I might add, I found it interesting in Freud's writings that our internal make-up as far as memory and how we process/store thoughts is the same. We are each equipped with what Freud refers to as Pcpti-C's and mnemic systems. It seems to be this "sameness" so to speak, that contributes to our own unique identities in terms of how we process information and how we "classify" it depending upon the severity of how it relates to us. With that said, it would be hard for any archive to fully be a direct correlation of the past because the individual or institution assembling is going to have a bias, whether conscious or unconscious, depending on what it is they're hoping to accomplish, want to remember, and/or feel is relevant to the recreation of a history. Archives are an indication, a signifier of the past. They ultimately "signify identity" as Boltanski puts it. So, why then? Why try and signify the past with physical indications when your memory according to Freud is designed to "archive" for you? I think it has to do with the visual interaction/participation that stems from the objects chosen. The objects were chosen for a specific reason because of their tangible ability to recreate a memory, a thought, a time, a place, a trace of the past.
Traces
After reading the artist’s texts in Traces, I wondered how much the influence of place, environment and the time lived have to do with their view of their archive. Freud’s thought about perceptions being present in the unconscious made me think abut how an artist can access and trigger past memories, or bring about new thought, influenced by experiences one has lived through. This notion was brought about after reading Kabakov's text for the third time (wink, wink). His writing reminded of a book I read long ago called One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovitch. This story details one day of a man imprisoned in a gulag where every little small thing becomes precious. Kabakov writing about something as base as garbage tells somewhat of a history story about Moscow at the onset of Gorbachov's Peristroika era. I found it interesting in reading afterwards Dore's link about Kabakov that one of the writers he admires is Solzhenitsyn, the author of One Day in the Life of I.D.
~B. Horiuchi
~B. Horiuchi
Friday, February 1, 2008
Feb. 5th artist discussion list with links
These are the artists Ron and I will be focusing on this coming Tuesday with interesting web sites:
Christian Boltanski
http://www.tate.org.uk/magazine/issue2/boltanski.htm
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE5DE1E30F931A25755C0A96E948260
http://www.icp.org/site/c.dnJGKJNsFqG/b.3829957/
Susan Hiller
http://www.susanhiller.org/
http://www.tate.org.uk/onlineevents/webcasts/susan_hiller/
Christian Boltanski
http://www.tate.org.uk/magazine/issue2/boltanski.htm
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE5DE1E30F931A25755C0A96E948260
http://www.icp.org/site/c.dnJGKJNsFqG/b.3829957/
Susan Hiller
http://www.susanhiller.org/
http://www.tate.org.uk/onlineevents/webcasts/susan_hiller/
Both Hiller and Boltanski refer to collecting objects (the archive) as a means of warding off death. I dont know if most hoarders are all sub-consciously searching for immortality or if they just get comfort from collecting and organizing. Foucault said that archeology is basically trying to find if what was said was actually true and Freud commented that psychology was privileged over archeology because the mind held purer un-fragmented truths. Maybe uncovering someones collection is the best of both because you can decipher their emotional state while examining their physical artifacts. I think all art making is an attempt to archive and avoid being forgotten.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)