Tuesday, May 6, 2008

JOHNNYS BLOG

In these articles there were some projects that were discussed that I responded to. One work was called 24 hr. psycho by Douglas Gordon – where he took that hitchcock film and slowed it down to “ a near catatonic running time”. – “ For Gordon , such pieces are ‘time readymades’- that is given narratives to be sampled in large image-projections ( a pervasive medium in art today)” I like this project because I think it forces the museum/gallery visitor to stay longer than he/she may have regularily stayed. Even a person who isn’t an art connosieur will recognize the hitchcock movie title “PSYCHO” and therefore pay more attention to the piece because of (famiarity)- giving more than just the 2 second stroll by that they would give to another (unfamiliar ) video piece.

And the other piece was “ For his part, Ben Kinmont approached randomly- selected people, offered to do their washing up for them and maintained an information network about his work.” I just thought this one sounded funny and I was thinking was he cleaning their houses, or doing their laundry, or giving them baths- really funny stuff either way= I wish I could find someone to bathe me and really get in those hard to reach spots. Ha ha ha .

Monday, May 5, 2008

One person’s utopia is another person’s hell.

I had heard this phrase and wondered where it came from.
I found an essay examining philosopher Agnes Heller and her husband Ferenc Feher and their criticism of Marxist utopian views [A Postmodern Utopia? Heller and Feher's Critique of Messianic Marxism, Journal article by Michael Gardiner; Utopian Studies, Vol. 8, 1997] and I began to think about this idea of utopia, microtopias and the Utopian Station.

"Utopia," they argue, "is the social condition under which all kinds of Utopias can be realized".
...
Each "major" utopia, understood as an imaginary construction of a form of life that foresees a successful fusion of goodness and human happiness, is inherently particularistic, especially in the context of postmodernity. Simply put, given the radical pluralization of contemporary society, one person's utopia is another's idea of hell, to paraphrase Max Beerbohm's famous maxim. As such, the best avenue is to enshrine the two meta-values of freedom and equal life-chances for all, and to give people the latitude and capacity to be able to visualize their own utopias. Utopia is a form of life that must be freely chosen; otherwise, it is a false promise, and a potentially tyrannical one.

Yet despite their questioning of the redemptive model of utopia, Heller and Feher, do not countenance a reconciliation with the impoverished and commodified reality of contemporary capitalism. This disavowal of the blueprint model of utopia does not mean Heller and Feher do not subscribe to a utopian vision of their own; it simply means they do not advocate it as a definitive solution for all humankind's ills.

From the readings, I glean the “utopia” definition has been altered dependent on who said what, when and where. Sir Thomas More’s idea of “utopia” is altered from Karl Marx’s idea “utopian socialism.” It has morphed just as the term “avant-garde” has been altered since 1863.

Nicolas Bourriaud’s microtopias, according to Claire Bishop in her Tate talk, are mini versions of the utopias which will not solve the world’s problems, but are just smaller, scaled down versions to reach harmony. Artists, through relational art, are just try to make it a bit better in the present time . She goes on...”instead of trying to change our world, artists are learning to inhabit our world in a better way.” She says, “Bourriaud states that it seems more pressing to invent possible relations with our neighbors in the present, than to bet on happier tomorrows.”

But then, who is to say and define what “utopia” is. Why is this the goal? Is the Utopian Station a relational way to search for dialog to begin a search? Then I go back to that Beerbohm maxim.

I have to agree with Hal Foster and the fine line artists tread when casting a wide net in relational art and, as he put it, the society of extras. I guess when I come down to it, I still appreciate the contemplative quiet I can glean from art made by an artist [singular] rather than the din of relational art.

Something (that we need) is Missing

The result of Adorno’s and Bloch’s debate on utopia described in “What is a Station?” boiled down to: something (that we need) is missing. According to Bloch we’ve lost the ability to imagine the totality as being something completely different. The promise of a perfect society through Marxism has failed in that respect but the desire to fill in that “something that is missing” has not faded with it. It has gone underground so to speak. Does this sound Freudian? It is taking each day one hill at a time.

Relational and social aesthetics suggest different ways of accomplishing this. Instead of viewing art as a utopian answer, autonomous, separated from everyday life and providing the viewer with a private space to experience those values not present to workers in a capitalist society, this week’s writers propose that the artists, like nomads, insert themselves into the social fabric of life and provide disruptions from within. Does this sound Foucauldian? The art they propose is no longer a tangible object but an encounter. The exhibition is no longer a space to walk through but a time frame to be experienced. Artists provide a situation or framework within which social interaction can occur, community can be created and meaning can be elaborated upon collectively. Sociability, conviviality, ethics and the everyday are important aspects of this encounter between art and the viewer/participant.

Foster feels the average viewer is not up to the task. Is he a part of the Frankfurt School who lost faith in the proletariat’s ability to carry out the revolution and felt it had to be left to the intellectuals instead? Or are we beyond these considerations. He worries about the lack of rigor in installations that form an analogy between an open work and an inclusive society, as if the structure of an art encounter alone will bring about an egalitarian democracy. He speaks of the “promiscuity of collaboration” brought on by the use of readily available information as the new readymade that brings up issues of authorship and originality. He wonders if partying is enough, if artists have lost their political and critical edge as well in what he describes as “happy interactivity” among aesthetic objects.

Utopia Station is described as a place to begin again, a field of starting points, a catalyst. After decades of deconstruction, dialectic clashes and conflict, we’ve come to a place where rebuilding, fusion, consensus, looking for relationships instead of divisions now takes the fore. When George Bush dismisses utopia, Nesbitt, Obrist and Tiravanija ask if that isn't reason enough to take it up again and revive the notion of a social vision that looks to the future. UCSC looks like a good a place as any to jump in…

Relational Art

As other have pointed out, Bourriauds concept of Relational Art argues for “human interaction and social context”, and that this has been brought about partly by urbanization of culture. Interestingly, on a side note from the main theme, he comments that our urban habitats have caused for a scaling down of objects, due to cramped spaces. Yet, from what I see in the contemporary photography market, prints are now expected to be huge and painting sized, especially in the commercial gallery market where a larger print (larger wall covering) demands a grossly disproportionately higher price than the production costs of a smaller print. Of course that turn about in print size has happened due to the technological changes in printing that have happened mostly since Bourriauds writing of 1998.

While the type Relational Art we are looking at is more performance based, I’m also looking to read this as how it also relates to contemporary photography. Bourriaud comments on the “collapsing” of the concepts of the traditional display of work and the now importance exhibitions that allow for a degree of immediacy and participation with the viewer. We now see artists who might describe themselves as a “Photographer”, yet are branching out into sculpture and video, and creating integrated “exhibitions” that ask for, and demand, a more complex experience than the more traditional display.

With the advent of “mega-exhibitions”, Hal Foster points out the current phenomenon of the artitst-curator and curator-artists, the “head of the team... the coach... the captain of the boat’’, etc., who uses the project as a venue for gathering and dispersal of people, and information. Thus, the culmination of human interaction and participatory art bound by social context.

Hal Foster does have some concerns about Relational Art, arguing that there is the risk of “illegibility” of the viewer, and that “surely one thing that art can do is take a stand... that brings out together the aesthetic, the cognitive and the critical.”
Pitting one form of art against another may not be productive. Allowing a multiplicity of working methods to exist simultaneously without a need to negate one or the other may be a more productive area for exploration. It could be a separate field of exploration. “The problem was no longer the expansion of the limits of art, but testing art’s capacity for resistance within the social field as a whole.” Also the idea that this kind of work is an “insertion” into the social fabric but does not take inspiration from it is appealing.

I think with work of this type (relational, participatory etc.) the indeterminate aspect is what is most appealing to me. I think working with groups of people, the unknown public, could introduce at the very least confusion, if not chaos and/or outright mayhem. This is good thing. I think that setting up a only partially planed event can lead to the most interesting results. I don’t think these event should be planned down to the last detail. I think giving up control or at least letting go of attachments to a particular outcome can be freeing.

Critical and Curatorial Positions

Globalization and advancements in technology are factors to relational art. At a time when social relations appear to be existing more on the computer and Internet communities such as myspace, facebook, email, etc. than real life social interaction, relational artists force participants to reengage with social relations through works which are based on present social conditions. When we say works, I am not sure I am using the correct term for relational art. This is because relational art is built around an interstice and not about the creation of an object of aura. Instead, subjectivity is used not create an art piece of aesthetic splendor but with the hopes of enriching social relationships with the world. But the aesthetic splendor is not used within the for of the object to promote a better functioning of society. Aesthetics are played out socially to remove the isolation and hierarchy between the artist and the viewer. For too long, the artist has been working in isolation and the viewer has viewed art without the presence of the artist. Can the aura of art objects be a result of the invisibility of the artist? Relational Art also appears to be the desire of Utopia, or the Other. But as we learn from the text "What is a station?", Utopia is a meeting place in which people are socially engaged through meetings and exchanges. Although Nesbit states technology is a small factor in utopia, I think technology plays a major part as a "way-station." Where else in the world can people meet and gather in a no-place to determine what is missing from present society/culture? In the end of the book, we are left to question whether collaboration and participation actually helps to promote discursivity and sociability as a practice? Although social art is supposedly about the everyday, the artist still takes the stand on social issues which forces the viewer to subjected to the artists' intentions. It appears that the artist might be directing the participation by the viewer which does not work in a lateral hierarchy. It seems to me the hardest part of social art might be the creation of an equal status between artist(s) and the viewer(s)/participant(s). In the end, art still takes a stand on the artist must defend the legendary ATC question: What/Where/Who/How/Why is the Art........?:)

Sunday, May 4, 2008

and more!

Utopia Station
Le Monde Diplomatique
August 2007


Kill Yourself Anywhere in the World for Under $399


No Ghost Just a Shell


Thomas Hirschhorn, Bataille Monument, 2002

Some Images from the Readings

I am part of the environmental fact.
The environmental fact consists of sets and sub sets of variable events.
Sets and sub sets of the variable event are encountered by chance.
The variable event has degrees of randability and probability.
I cannot predict an event I can only measure its probability.
The environmental fact becomes a random event.
I must learn to live with the random event and except it as an intricate part of the total whole.
Stephen Willats, The Random Event (1961)


Gabriel Orozco, Crazy Tourist, 1991


Gordon Matta-Clark, Food


'Untitled' (Public Opinion), 1991 by Gonzalez-Torres


Floating Platform and Spaceframe, 2001


Lincoln Tobier with Simon Leung, Utopia Station, Venice Biennale, 2003

Critical and Curatorial Positions

It seems to me that some of the situational happenings/exhibitions/installations/conferences/seminars/events/gatherings etc.. seem to revolve around the dialog within the art community as to the validity of this type of art practice. A good majority of our readings speak more about practice than to the success of the work to make change in society. I wonder if some of the artist's desire to create original work is masked under the facade of a rejection to the standard gallery aesthetic and system. Hal Foster's concerns of "a risk of illegibility" and collaboration for the sake of collaboration are valid. I do think that this sort of practice is important and often is successful when done within the proper environment. Our own UCSC intervention project is probably doomed to really be successful because of the premise of the event. How can we really interrupt or intervene a community that is in attendance to see interruptions and interventions. The minute you call something an intervention it seizes to be one. Its like when your favorite underground band puts out that big label studio album and still tries to act like hardcore street kids.

Relational Art, the Individual, the Community and the Space in Between

Bourriaud asserts that contemporary art, moreover relational art, allows for inter-human relations, creating a dialogue between viewers and ideally setting up a sense of community that seems to be lacking in a world that has posited the machine as the new human. Relational art functions as an open work encouraging critical thinking within the individual and an exchange of ideas between viewers as a group. Bourriaud also writes about the interstice which “suggests possibilities for exchanges other than those that prevail within the system.” (161) Interstices are created between the artwork and the viewer, and then again between the viewer and the community. Each of these spaces allows for the possibility of exchange, first individually and then socially. Bourriaud’s ideas about relational art are not that dissimilar to the nineteenth ideas of Kant and Schiller regarding aesthetic experience and the development of taste by a community. Aesthetic experience is something that happens within the individual, but taste is something that is conceived collaboratively by a community through the open exchange of ideas. This space, I would think, is important for any piece of art as it needs a viewer to fulfill its purpose as a visual work.

I understand the criticisms of Hal Foster about the downfalls of relational art, such as the art becoming only about viewer experience, which then runs the risk of it not being understood in which case it would fail as a work, but can’t relational art just be an idea- an idea to structure art, artistic themes, or future genres around? And furthermore, isn’t the idea of creating a visual work based on the notion of it being seen and reflected upon? Otherwise, why create a visual work which is in symbolic on account of it being a visual creation?

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Tate Talk

There is a really great 25 minute long talk given by Claire Bishop (editor of our Participation book) on "Utopias and Microtopias: Contemporary Art in the 1990's" from the Tate Museum's study days online lectures. She discusses the spectacle, Debord and hybrid performance installation art that has come in vogue since the 1990's, among other things relavant to the last reading. I thought it might be of interest given our upcoming gig and talk in class this week about all this. Here is an excerpt of some of what she says....

...the kind of work where the art is conceived as a context for social interaction and using the gallery as a social space. ... it is much more about including an audience within this and the experience of the gallery space. ...[it is a] hybrid of performance and installation art but it is a significant development of both. It differs from performance art in the viewers that perform in the space rather than the artist. And it differs from installation in which the work requires we use the space rather than just looking at it and deciphering it's meaning from the specific arrangement of objects. The emphasis in this kind of project is on the collective presence and interaction and on the dissolution of the commodifiable art object into a social encounter. ...

http://www.tate.org.uk/learning/studydays/utopia_avant_gardes/

If you scroll down, it is Session 5.

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

johnnys blog

I liked the music and movie references in the helio article referring to Nat King Cole covering mediocre songs but making them great songs ,due to his exceptional ability; “ creating a vocal expressive structure that is independent from the song he interprets. This is a creation that is not simply interpretative but pertains to a highly expressive vocalist. An actor such as Marilyn Monroe for example, due to her all-encompassing interpretative presence, possesses above all else a creative quality, which is structurally expressive. Her presence in certain mediocre films makes these films uncommonly interesting, a fact that is due to her action as interpreter. What is interesting here is the vocalization of Nat and the interpretative act of Marilyn, independent of the quality of the interpreted score or script, even if these possess , of course, a value that is relative and not absolute as before.” I think some more current examples could be maybe Madonna in the movie “deperately seeking suzan”- I know some young women that idolize her character in that movie, and Madonna’s interpretative presence makes the movie memorable (at least to some people anyway.)

I thought the notes on funk article had a lot of useful points in it for our class to examine for our respeaking event; like the number of people in the inside room when a person does a repeaking for example ( if theres more than 8 it probably will change the dynamics and feel of the moment giving it a party type atmosphere.) I feel that the quotes and music and images we chose(content) will be far less of the determinant on a successful outcome of the event as a whole: as will factors like collaboration,collectiveness, and most importanly participation. I think at this point in our process we should be putting the majority of our energies into figuring out ways to get as many people as we can to REALLY PARTICIPATE in the karaoke jam. “ get down and party together” is the real art here. Right?

Monday, April 28, 2008

The readings seem to point to art used as a force for change within society. The student riots of 1968 or punk may not have happened if situationist theory was not around. I wonder what its effect is today. Is it possible that some of the techniques of the situationists have in some way been taken up by the very agencies that they were fighting against? Debords own films use techniques of pairing seemingly contrasting images and sound. This seems to be everywhere now. It is even used in advertising itself.
Could it be that painting on an easel - alone and unconnected - could be one of the most revolutionary and healing acts performed today?
What these articles made me start thinking about is the role of the artist vs. the role of the audience and how they cannot exist without one or the other.
But when crossing the boundary between the roles of the two, exist the participant. In these articles, the artists are collectively creating an art piece based on the audience/ participation/ experience of the audience, "controlled situations" and/or "Environmental Constructions".

Kaprow argues that if the audience eliminated and just participants remained, it would create a more successful “Happening”. I’m not so sure I agreed with this. When one exists within an event and one exist merely as a bystander of the event, different perspectives, memories, and experiences are created. I do not see how this is a negative aspect. Also, he suggests that the works are inappropriate to exist within a gallery setting. I think this reflects back to an earlier discussion in class, last week, regarding the re-speaking videos we watched. How some suggested that the re-speaking “loose” something when presented into such a controlled space, environment, and crowd.

In respect to our Re-Speakings, not all audience members will be participants, but without the audience the participants are non-existent. For example, if the class is the only participants, and the audience is just there to watch the Happening. What is the importance of a spectacle of an event/happening? What is the importance of presenting the re-speaking to this crowd? How does this begin to create a collective memory of not only this event (the Conference) and the original event (the one re-spoken), and how do the two work within one another, the context of this social gathering, and audience??

Vague boundaries between Art & Life

As Sally mentioned, these readings perhaps raise more questions than provide answers. Ah, but isn’t that the roll of art? Or, I’d prefer to say one of the many possible rolls or art. And not to sound to trite, the topic of what makes these works “art” was constantly on my mind. It’s not my questioning weather these works are art, but it’s more the curiosity of the vague boundary that exists, and what is crossed to put these in the art realm.

Kaprow stresses the need in a Happening to avoid a “group of inactive People” or “dead space”, to avoid the suggestion of a theatre production. He argues the importance of willing participants to have the knowledge of the scheme. Yet, Carnevale work crosses that barrier by forcing spectators in to being participants in what could be a dangers and violent situation? At one point does something that could be described as a crime of imprisonment on one hand, then transition into an artistic expression?

At what point does Beuy’s soap box lectures and discussions on Democracy transcend from political commentary to an artistic presentation. Of course his answer to that question to the girl at 3:00pm was “A special type of art. One can think with.” Is it because it is held in a Gallery presentation? And then Group Material puts together a “forum” on Democracy with round table Discussions, Exhibition, Town Meeting, and the all important Book for Documentation. If this “forum” were held at a City Hall or convention center instead of the at the Dia Arts Foundation, how would that change effect it’s meaning and interpretation?

And while were at, let’s all “get down and party”. That sounds good to me, and as Adrian Piper points out with her series of Funk Lesson “participatory social events”, “everyone participates in a collectively shared, enjoyable experience. Good enough, I’ve taken some dance lessons in a group setting; Ball room, Swing, Salsa, and that quote would explains the same experience. But, Is a Dance/Music appreciation class taught by an “artist” more art than one taught by a dancer?

Again, I’m not questioning these artists and practices as not being art, I’m just pondering the subtle and complex unseen boundary between art and life.

Charging Batteries: Moving From Passive to Empowered

What this week's readings drove home for me is that there are degrees of participation and there are a myriad of structures, situations and methods for bringing this about. Whether these “artworks” are successful is dependent on the both the intention of the artist, the process of what occurs and the actual outcome of the situations, if these things can even be measured. All are open to interpretation. Bishop says her concerns in this section on artists’ writings was to bring up the issues of activation, authorship and community as well as to show a number of different approaches to documentation. For me it raises questions instead of providing definitive answers. Debord was interested in subverting the effects of capitalism through the creation of active and empowered subjects where the audience of spectators become those who live. Others, like Piper were more interested in appropriating existing social forms to produce new social relations and new social realities through audience empowerment. Do we play games and party with fully cooperating and cognizant participants? Or do we take prisoners and bring up all those negative emotions, fear, anxiety and anger in the face of aggression, violence and coercion? Hirshhorn, Tiravanija, Group Material, Collective Actions provide alternatives to Carnavale in the amount of structure and direction provided. Tiravanija’s retrospective was certainly ethereal. I could see people thinking of it as a hoax. How do you show a retrospective of participatory art when no documentation exists? Do traces of past participants who lived in the original exhibition spaces remain in the empty structures that are recreated for the retrospective? Is it enough to show the equivalent of a blank screen, have a docent provide a verbal narrative for viewers who then use their own imaginations to create their own mental, interactive video and project it onto the space? People can participate or resist to whatever degree they choose. At the other end of the scale is Hirshhorn’s 24h Foucault where the energy of Foucault’s philosophy is given form in what Hirshhorn calls a charged battery. He doesn’t want people to necessarily understand Foucault’s ideas, he want them to experience Foucault through eight different settings filled with activities and objects with which people can interact, to be inside “the brain in action” and to emerge changed, and charged, from the experience. The audiences' actual responses to these different interventions is alluded to by Piper, Deller and Group Material but not by other artists who express what they hope will happen or indicate what they learned from the experiences themselves...

So does our UCSC project transform us from an audience of spectators who read, listen, watch and discuss things within the hermetically sealed community of our classroom to living artists who through our creation and example become the battery that charges a different group of spectators and empowers them as well? And who will determine the success of our endeavor? Will our own documentation present only our point(s) of view or will the experience of our audience of participants and spectators be considered as well?

Sunday, April 27, 2008

Debord says, " What alters the way we see the streets is more important than what alters the way we see painting."  In this, I feel he is suggesting that our goal as artists is to change the everyday perspective, not just affecting the minority that may see our work in a gallery or museum setting and be "touched" by its emotive or controversial qualities.  In thinking about that, I find it amusing and interesting the way Adrian Piper gives her "Funk Lessons".  She is not only investigating individual issues of identity and communication, but also trying to breakdown social and cultural barriers of understanding one another, in the streets, so to speak.

I agree with Camille that these articles seem idealistic.  In reading Beuys, it is hard for me to imagine every single person taking the role of artist.  I mean, I have a hard time thinking George Bush would consider himself an artist, and if he would, what those notions of art would be.

Kaprow, Participation, and the Archons

With all of the email correspondence that has been going on this last week, (i.e. lab coats versus t-shirt, balloons, no balloons), Kaprow's "Notes on the Elimination of the Audience" really got me thinking on how our piece is going to be an interactive piece, other than the actual respeaking. In short, Kaprow asserts that the audience needs to be eliminated, there should be only participants, to make a "Happening" successful. When there is an audience the expectation of a totally staged theatrical peformance is anticipated. A barrier between the performers or participants, and the audience automatically forms. Kaprow refers to this space as "dead space." He writes "All the elements- people, space, the particular materials and character of the environment, time- can in this way be integrated." (103) I think that this is what many of us had been grappling with before the idea to perform a kind of "diagnostic" test on participants to see, I'm assuming, what respeaking might be applicable or best suited for them. I think it will be an interesting way to not only encourage participation from the audience members, but will give our class another way to contribute and participate. This allows for the project to be more interactive and complex, other than just the respeaking.
This too falls in line with what Kaprow says that, "it is a mark of mutual respect that all persons involved in a Happening be willing and committed participants."

Which brings me to my next point, I really didn't like Graciela Carnevale's way of "forced" participation from audience members to prove a point about the passiveness of people in a society where violence ensures all around. Still in accordance with Kaprow, I think that participants need to understand what they are participating in, otherwise, to me, it seems like a form of trickery where the artist gets the last laugh.

Get Down and Party. Together. - Democracy at its best? Maybe.

Joseph Beuys pointed out the idealism of the situationist aims in “I Am Searching for a Field Character,” when he said, “...Social Sculpture/ Social Architecture – will only reach fruition when every living person becomes a creator, a sculptor or architect of the social organism.” I suppose in some ways we already all form the “social organisms” that we take part in. Yet, the equality or democracy that is the crux of the artworks in question does not exist in our social structures. Of the pieces included in our readings, there was really only one that may have gotten close to forming a democratic social organism. This was The Baudouin/ Boudewijn Experiment. Although, it would be interesting to know what actually occurred in the room meant for serious inactivity. Did certain people become the center of attention and thus performative while others became spectators? Or was there really democracy through inactivity? Should we forget about the meaning in the duty of the person whose role it was to lock the door to the outside? I guess what I am driving at is the inherent idealism in these projects. Don’t get me wrong. I think that it is one of the roles of the artist to drive society towards ideals. And it seems that some change is initiated through the attempts to create situations in which true democracy is the goal. Adrian Piper’s piece seemed the most successful in creating social change through action and learning. However, this was not at first a true democratic system. She was initially acting somewhat in the manner of a dictator leading people through an experimental process meant to “transmit and share a physical language that everyone was then empowered to use.” Eventually people began to interact and the situation took on a life of its own, but it was not a situation arrived at through a democratic basis. The situation was chosen by a single person and others followed. Thus, the situationist framework could be used for good and bad. Regardless, Piper’s lessons did lead to a diminishing in the passivity of the public. On the other hand, Beuys’ “Bureau for Direct Democracy” only led to interaction with 35 visitors out of the total eight hundred and eleven. This kind of ratio seems closer to the one that I think we will have at UC Santa Cruz. While our re-speaking only bears some resemblance to the aims of the situationists – it involves the audience for one thing – it differs in some ways as well – there will be a hierarchy inherent to the process, for example in the use of lab coats. But, the archival material we are using draws attention to past events of importance in a way that will hopefully involve everyone by calling attention to characteristics of our larger social organism. Idealistically this would in turn cause those involved to become a creator of that social organism in at least some small way.

a few more

top two images are Hirschhorn's 24th Foucault
Deller "Battle of Orgreave"
Tiravanija's NY apartment