Monday, April 28, 2008

Charging Batteries: Moving From Passive to Empowered

What this week's readings drove home for me is that there are degrees of participation and there are a myriad of structures, situations and methods for bringing this about. Whether these “artworks” are successful is dependent on the both the intention of the artist, the process of what occurs and the actual outcome of the situations, if these things can even be measured. All are open to interpretation. Bishop says her concerns in this section on artists’ writings was to bring up the issues of activation, authorship and community as well as to show a number of different approaches to documentation. For me it raises questions instead of providing definitive answers. Debord was interested in subverting the effects of capitalism through the creation of active and empowered subjects where the audience of spectators become those who live. Others, like Piper were more interested in appropriating existing social forms to produce new social relations and new social realities through audience empowerment. Do we play games and party with fully cooperating and cognizant participants? Or do we take prisoners and bring up all those negative emotions, fear, anxiety and anger in the face of aggression, violence and coercion? Hirshhorn, Tiravanija, Group Material, Collective Actions provide alternatives to Carnavale in the amount of structure and direction provided. Tiravanija’s retrospective was certainly ethereal. I could see people thinking of it as a hoax. How do you show a retrospective of participatory art when no documentation exists? Do traces of past participants who lived in the original exhibition spaces remain in the empty structures that are recreated for the retrospective? Is it enough to show the equivalent of a blank screen, have a docent provide a verbal narrative for viewers who then use their own imaginations to create their own mental, interactive video and project it onto the space? People can participate or resist to whatever degree they choose. At the other end of the scale is Hirshhorn’s 24h Foucault where the energy of Foucault’s philosophy is given form in what Hirshhorn calls a charged battery. He doesn’t want people to necessarily understand Foucault’s ideas, he want them to experience Foucault through eight different settings filled with activities and objects with which people can interact, to be inside “the brain in action” and to emerge changed, and charged, from the experience. The audiences' actual responses to these different interventions is alluded to by Piper, Deller and Group Material but not by other artists who express what they hope will happen or indicate what they learned from the experiences themselves...

So does our UCSC project transform us from an audience of spectators who read, listen, watch and discuss things within the hermetically sealed community of our classroom to living artists who through our creation and example become the battery that charges a different group of spectators and empowers them as well? And who will determine the success of our endeavor? Will our own documentation present only our point(s) of view or will the experience of our audience of participants and spectators be considered as well?

No comments: