Monday, April 14, 2008

Nancy and Ranciere: Death and Consensus

I agree with Jenny that the general tenor of many of our readings has been one of decline, dissolution, a downward spiral ending in death, from Derrida to Boltanski, from Barthes to Merewether’s account of Japanese photography after Hiroshima, from Buchloh’s accounts of the anomic archives of Warburg and Richter to Burger’s negation of the autonomy of the avant-garde.
Jean-Luc Nancy’s Inoperative Community follows Barthes’ Death of the Author with a redefining of community. Like Barthes’ attempt to shift the focus of meaning of a work from the author and its point of origin to the reader and its final destination, Nancy proposes defining community as an unraveling (disoeuvrement) of cohesion brought about by the death of individuals, the only certainty in life. You may disagree, but I find him to be a very convoluted but binary thinker positing things in terms of either/or, A and not A, a thing and its opposite, as opposed to taking a more encompassing Kierkegaardian "both/and" approach. For example he quotes Sartre who defines communism as “the unsurpassable horizon of our time” (54). The “not Sartre”, according to Nancy, is communism as an emblem of the desire of a place "beyond social divisions, beyond subordination to technopolitical dominion, beyond the wasting away of liberty, speech and happiness in privatization... a place to surmount the unraveling that occurs with the death of each of us" (54). This is communism as utopia. He goes on to say how some feel betrayed by the totalitarian state that subverted this utopian ideal but says this feeling is untenable because the destruction of the ideal was a seed carried within its internal logic from the time of its inception.
Some of his explanations of the dual nature of things reminded me of this weekend’s talk at the Art History Symposium by Michael Shanks who examined the boundary between figure and ground, between the edge of the hole of an archaeological dig and what surrounds it, between inside and outside. Nancy speaks of the atom as an indivisible part, a building block of the universe that is also a world in itself, and the individual as Subject, “the absolute-for-itself,” that is closed off from relations that define community. But to be closed off implies something to be closed off from, there is an inside and an outside and this implies a relationship between the two. Nancy says the underlying message has always been about community whether or not this was consciously understood.
In tracing the historical roots of the breakdown of community that brought about the modern era, (what he calls horizons behind us), he introduces the historical idea of the lost community. This is a place of unity, intimacy, and harmony that we look back to with nostalgia and that we have been seeking since the beginning of Western history. According to Nancy, this originates in a Christian yearning for communion (union) with God that implies a return to the idea of the divine that is immanent in all things human. What we are mourning is the withdrawal of this perceived divinity in contemporary society. I find his idea that this lost community never actually existed but is a myth to be interesting. According to Rosalind Krauss, the function of myth is to help us deal with contradictions by covering them over, by repressing the part of the past that doesn’t appeal to us. Although Nancy does not use the term myth, communism as utopia and the lost community of the past both fit this description. It is an escape from “the social bond (relations, communication), our own invention, (that) now descends heavily like the net of an economic, technical, political and cultural snare. Entangled in its meshes, we have wrung for ourselves the phantasm of the lost community” (62).
As Kirk and Barb point out, in Problems and Transformations of Critical Art, Ranciere continues a rhetoric of oppositions: art and non-art, readability and non-readability, the politics of aesthetics and the aesthetics of politics. However, he proposes that instead of getting caught up in a vicious cycle of exclusion that we look instead at underlying commonalities. He characterizes our time as one of consensus in which public space has shrunk and political polemic inventiveness as been effaced and parodied. This change is reflected in the mystery of the art of Jean-Luc Godard in which the kinship of the heterogeneous is emphasized and of Christian Boltanski in which the examination of stereotypes shifts toward the borders between the familiar and the uncanny, the real and the symbolic. One result of game playing, one theme of contemporary exhibitions, is the suspension of original meaning of certain works of art, like collages whose heterogeneous elements were meant to shock and make people aware of the political and economic realities represented by the images. Their originally intended value as political polemic statements comes into question. He closes his essay by stating that this undecidability leads to opposing feelings: “melancholy regarding the shared world that art carried within itself, as if this had not been betrayed by political...or commercial compromises; and in others, an awareness of its limits,” a continuation of Nancy’s themes.

No comments: