Benjamin discusses that photography produces a magical value in a way that painting cannot. He states "photography reveals something about the unconscious. The camera acts as our unconscious while our eye is our unconscious." But it seems to me that Benjamin might be contradicting himself to the way we read images. Although certain photographs may resonate an unconscious or spiritual response, don't we resonate language and memory when we read images as well? Benjamin contradicts his statement about the eye and the unconscious when discussing the scientific empiricism of August Sander's portraits of the German social body. As a result, if we read Sander's portraits this way, we would be reacting to the knowledge and language from scientific discourse. I think we all read images in different ways. When looking at the following link Sander's image "Pastrycook," do you react via your unconscious or your conscious...I think it depends on the image and the photograph's representative discourse.
http://www.metmuseum.org/special/August_Sander/2.L.htm
Ricoeur's writing is interesting because he does not take the obvious route in his discussion of archival deposits taking on meaning through the institutional activity it is situated in. Instead, Ricoeur challenges the monumentality of archive through the emergence of positivist history. By adapting to positivist history, the document becomes the monument which, according to Ricoeur, results in the loss of historical meaning/memory by the powerful.
Allan Sekula discusses the penal discourse of the 19th century police apparatus and the attempt to character, brand, and individualize criminals through the disciplines of physiognomy and phrenology. The emergence of photography allowed the police apparatus to utilize the Panopticon mechanism to situate criminals in vision and in which the criminals were caught up in a power relation. It seems that the penal discourse of the 19th century is similar to the discourse of the Patriot Act by the U.S. Government to characterize and individualize the so-called terrorists. By using the discipline of physiognomy, it appears the U.S. Government is telling us to be aware of the character of anyone that threatens or intends to harm the United States. The U.S. government disseminates photographs of the Terrorist Watch List. So, my question is, in a present day and age when we challenge the Bush Administration and the U.S. Government for the absurdness of the Patriot Act, can there ever be an apparatus that can be truthful?? It would seem to me that the police apparatus of the 19th century and the U.S. government apparatus of the 21st century use the optical realism of the photograph to create knowledge which, whether agreed with or not, we are the bearers and are responsible for this subjection. So, although we may disagree with an apparatus, we are all responsible for the incarcerated criminals who may be innocent and the lynching of Saddam Hussein because we are the law-abiding bourgeosie.
I look forward to learning more about the Derrida piece. I have read it numerous times and I am still lost.
Look forward to class tomorrow.
Monday, February 11, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment